Have you ever wondered if those adverts offering supplements to improve your health are any good at meeting their claims?
💊 On Supplements:
You’re absolutely right to be sceptical, a huge proportion of supplement marketing is driven by profit (estimated at $170 billion in 2024), not science. While a handful of supplements are backed by solid evidence (like vitamin D in people with deficiency, or folic acid in pregnancy), the majority are:
-
Poorly regulated
-
Light on clinical evidence
-
Sold with exaggerated or misleading claims
“Boosts immunity”, “clears brain fog”, and “supports detox” are often vague, non-clinical buzzwords with no defined standard or measurable outcome. Worse, some supplements can:
-
Interact dangerously with prescription medications
-
Be contaminated or inaccurately dosed
-
Provide false reassurance that delays proper care
💉 On Pharma:
It’s also true that the pharmaceutical industry isn’t free of criticism.
However, unlike supplements, prescription medications must:
-
Undergo rigorous multi-phase trials
-
Be approved by regulators like the MHRA, FDA, or EMA
-
Disclose known risks and benefits
In short, supplements often promise more than they can prove, while pharmaceuticals prove more than they promise.
Here’s a clear summary of supplements with solid clinical evidence for specific medical uses — separating useful options from hype:
✅ Supplements With Strong Evidence (When Used Appropriately)
| Supplement | Evidence-Based Use | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Vitamin D | Deficiency, osteoporosis prevention, possibly immune support in deficiency | Especially important in the UK due to low sunlight. Blood levels should guide use. |
| Vitamin B12 | B12 deficiency, especially in vegans or people with absorption issues (e.g. pernicious anaemia) | Supplements or injections needed if deficiency confirmed. |
| Folic Acid | Preventing neural tube defects in pregnancy | Universal NHS recommendation for women trying to conceive and in first trimester. |
| Iron (ferrous sulphate, etc.) | Iron deficiency anaemia | Should be taken under medical advice due to GI side effects and overdose risk. |
| Calcium + Vitamin D | Osteoporosis prevention in older adults or people on long-term steroids | Often used with bisphosphonates in bone health management. |
| Omega-3 fatty acids (EPA/DHA) | Lowering triglycerides; heart health in specific populations | Prescription versions (e.g. icosapent ethyl) more effective than OTC versions. |
| Iodine | Pregnancy, thyroid deficiency in areas of low intake | Often included in pregnancy supplements. Too much is harmful. |
| Magnesium | Certain deficiencies, muscle cramps, possibly in migraine prevention | May cause diarrhoea at high doses. |
| Zinc | Shortening cold duration (minor effect), deficiency | No clear benefit in general population; high doses harmful. |
| Probiotics | Antibiotic-associated diarrhoea, Clostridioides difficile prevention, IBS symptoms (strain-specific) | Evidence is strain-dependent. Most supermarket probiotics = weak effect. |
⚠️ Supplements With Limited or Mixed Evidence
| Supplement | Claims vs. Reality |
|---|---|
| Turmeric/curcumin | Anti-inflammatory effects shown in lab studies, but poor absorption limits real-world impact unless specially formulated. |
| Echinacea | Minor cold symptom relief in some studies, but overall results inconsistent. |
| Glucosamine/Chondroitin | Mixed results for osteoarthritis pain. May help some, but large trials show modest effect at best. |
| Coenzyme Q10 | Some benefit in statin-related muscle pain or rare mitochondrial disorders, but expensive and not always effective. |
| Multivitamins | No benefit in preventing cancer, heart disease, or cognitive decline in healthy adults. May help in poor nutrition. |
❌ Supplements With Little or No Reliable Benefit
-
Detox supplements — your liver and kidneys do this already.
-
“Immune boosters” — vague and often meaningless without underlying deficiency.
-
Weight loss pills — usually ineffective or risky.
-
Memory boosters (ginkgo biloba, etc.) — no proven benefit in large trials.
-
Anti-cancer or longevity pills — often pseudoscientific.
🧠 Final Advice
-
Supplements can fill a gap, not replace real treatment.
-
Ask: “Is there a proven deficiency, or a real clinical goal?”
-
Always check interactions, especially if you’re on medications.
-
For rare diseases or chronic conditions, it’s safest to ask a consultant pharmacist or specialist before trying anything new.
Latest News posts
News archive